Vivid Light Photography, digital and film photography online
Just Burn it to Disk - Not So Fast!
<<Back  Page 1  2  3  



How CDs & DVDs Work

Whether we're talking about CDs or DVDs there are two basic disk types - read-only and writable. They differ in structure, materials, and manufacturing technology. 

When large numbers of copies are needed, read only disks are the natural choice because the discs are stamped from molds. The molding process (which is not unlike how phonograph records are made) forms a polycarbonate disc that makes up the bulk of the finished CD. This molded disc has a spiral track of pits impressed on one side; these pits embody the encoded data. As the laser beam in a CD player is guided along the length of the track, it is interrupted by the pits. These interruptions are decoded into music, text, or pictures.

Diagram Courtesy of Kodak

When it leave the mold it's only a clear plastic disc with tiny pits; if you tried to read it, the reading laser would pass right through it, never "seeing" a difference between a pit and a land (a smooth area). That's why disks have a silvery or gold metallic coating. The metallic layer forms a reflective surface from which the laser light bounces back into a light-sensing detector. When the tightly focused laser beam reflects off a land, the light-sensing detector "sees" the beam. When the beam encounters a pit, no laser light is reflected into the light-sensing detector.

This metallic reflective layer has been a source of problems in disc longevity. CD-ROM technology, which originated around 1980, is older than writable CD technology. As with any new product, there were lessons to be learned and improvements to be made. The reflecting layer was a case in point. In CD-ROMs, the reflecting layer is actually aluminum or a chrome-aluminum alloy, not silver. The metal is applied to the pit side of the molded polycarbonate disc by means of "sputter" coating, in which atoms of metal are deposited as a very thin film in a high-vacuum chamber. Thin metal films are semitransparent. A familiar example are "mirrored" sunglasses.

If the metallic layer in a disk ceases to be reflective, then there can be problems reading its data. In some early CD-ROMs (and in some low quality disks being manufactured today), the metallic layer gradually loses its ability to reflect a laser beam, especially when discs are stored in warm or humid conditions. The problem is oxidation of the aluminum. Oxidation makes the discs more transparent in the affected areas, sometimes almost clear. 

The use of aluminum alloys improved the resistance to oxidation. Today, disks from quality manufacturers have a predicted life of over one hundred years in normal storage conditions and up to two hundred years in archival storage conditions. 

How can you determine whether a disk is manufactured to the highest standards of quality? Unfortunately, it's not possible to tell by looking. But it is possible to get some clues.

The metallic layers of disk have varying degrees of transparency. By holding a CD-ROM up close to the eye in front of a strong light source, you can see how transparent the metallic layer is unless a label or heavy printing prevents this. Some CD-ROMs are opaque, some almost opaque, and others almost transparent. Those that are quite transparent may be more susceptible to oxidation damage. You will also see gold disks on the market. Gold is well known for its superior oxidation resistance. Should you pay for the extra insurance of a gold disk? How much life insurance should you purchase? It's a question only you can answer.

What's the Difference Between CDs and DVDs?

CDs and DVDs use essentially the same technology. The primary difference is that DVD, a newer technology developed in 1997, packs more information onto the disk. It does this by using a thinner laser that can read more tightly packed pits and lands on the disk. But for most of this discussion when we say "disk" the information can be applied interchangeably to either format. For more information on how DVDs differ from CDs and about new DVD Blue Laser technologies see A New DVD Standard below

How Does a CD or DVD deal with Scratches and Dirt?

The metallic layer in all types of disks requires protection from physical wear and tear as well as from airborne contaminants that could cause oxididation. The super-thin metal film is delicate and would be damaged easily if unprotected. On the top of the disk a clear layer of lacquer protects the metallic reflecting layer. The main job of the lacquer is to protect the metallic layer. It also forms a surface upon which a label can be printed.

The bottom of the disk (the data side) is molded polycarbonate. The polycarbonate is a clear layer that the pits are read through. It is also the layer that absorbs all the bumps, scratches and abuse that we heap on our disks. 

The lens of the reading laser focuses the beam directly on the pits through the 1.2-millimeter thickness of the polycarbonate with a very shallow "depth of field". This allows the beam to "look past" scratches, which are out of focus, unless they're really deep. 

The disk reading software that decodes the data stored on the disc also includes the ability to detect and to some extent correct errors found in the data. This error correction software takes advantage of the fact that some cross checking and redundancy are built into both formats. Error correction in generally more effective for images and music than for programs.

Working together the laser's ability to focus past surface defects and the software's ability to detect and correct errors make both the CD and DVD formats amazingly fault tolerant. I've seen disks with an amazing amount of physical damage that were still readable. But when archiving irreplaceable data you shouldn't count on that fault tolerance. I've also seen disks that looked fine rendered unreadable by a single deep pit or scratch in the wrong place. 

Diagram Courtesy of Kodak

CDs are scratch-tolerant because the reading laser beam's point of focus is on the upper side of the disc substrate. Scratches on the lower side of the substrate are "out of focus."

The Bottom Line

Buy high quality disks. Store them well. Upgrade as formats and machines change and your data will be safe for a lifetime. 

Ignore these simple guidelines and you will eventually experience that "kicked in the gut" sick feeling when you realize that a disk full of irreplaceable images has been lost.

A New DVD Standard

DVD stands for either Digital Video Disc or Digital Versatile Disc - depending on who you ask. 

DVDs and CDs are the same size and thickness and both are based on a similar principle: tiny pits represent information that a laser beam in the player reads. A DVD uses a smaller, thinner infrared laser that can read more densely packed data. The DVD disc's tracks are laid out closer together than a CD so more information can be crammed into the same space. A single-sided DVD disc, for example, has seven times the capacity of a compact disc. A hologram lens is used to split the beam so the player can read both DVDs and CDs.

All current CD and DVD readers/players use red lasers which have seemingly been on the market forever. But a new DVD format using blue lasers is on the horizon and there are two competing versions. Blu-ray disks hold more data but are incompatible with current DVDs while HD DVD holds less data but will be able to read all current DVDs. Hitachi, LG, Matsushita, Pioneer, Philips, Samsung, Sharp, Sony, Thomson, Mitsubishi, Dell and HP all support the Blu-ray format, while Toshiba and NEC support the HD DVD format. 

Why are so many manufacturers supporting a format that is incompatible with current DVDs? Size. Blu-ray disks have almost double the capacity of HD DVD disks (15 GB to 27 GB). Toshiba and NEC favor HD DVD technology because the disks can be mastered and replicated using existing equipment and processes. 

Why should you care? Because we're all moving to High Definition television (HD TV) in the next few years, and the new Blu-ray blue laser format can hold a two hour high definition movie on a single DVD. Manufacturers are working on the compatibility issues and feel that by late 2005 to early 2006 these players will be ready for market and able to read existing disks.  

So how do blue laser DVDs compare with existing CDs and red laser DVDs? A CD can hold around 650 MB of data. A current DVD holds around 4.7 GB, or around seven times more data than a CD. Blue laser disks marketed under the name "Blu-ray Disks" hold 27 GB of data - the equivalent of over 41 CDs or almost six DVDs. 

HD TV is forcing many changes on the consumer electronics and broadcast industries. Who would have thought that photographers would benefit as well?

Images Courtesy of Kodak
We wish to thank Kodak, 3M and Sony for providing 
information for this article.



<<Back  Page 1  2  3  


  Subscribe to Vivid Light 
Photography by email 

Tell Us What You Think

Vivid Light Photography, digital and film photography online

All materials contained herein Copyright Vivid Light Photography Magazine 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004